Just wanted to add a note saying that I’m having the exact same problem.
Thus far, even deactivating and uninstalling the plugin and clearing the cache has not worked for me.
I have really found this plugin useful in the past, but I sincerely hope you can rectify this problem as quickly as possible.
Thanks
Just realized I never marked this as resolved. The solution James put forth worked perfectly. Many thanks!
That makes sense. I’ll go ahead and do another transfer as suggested and then set the old site to private.
Thanks so much for your help James, I’ll let you know how it works out!