Update: Well I ran into an issue that might help someone with a little more knowledge than me. With not being able to get any of my current category feeds to work in Google Reader I tried creating a new category called “test” and posted a new blog entry. I then went back to the reader and tried to subscribe to the “test” category that I just created and it worked! What is going on with my wordpress that is letting the feed from a newly created category work, but not the old ones? Here is some of my site info that I forgot to add in my previous post.
WP 2.5.1
Plugins that I’ve read could interfere: Feedburner Feedsmith 2.3.1, PodPress 8.8
I’ve tried disabling both of these but it doesn’t help my feed problem at all.