User Selected Image Not Working

Until today I have been able to have my images as user selected to be pinned. Now it is suddenly not working that way. It will only allow the first image of a post to be pinned directly. I have tried deactivating all other plugins, clearing the browser cache and using a different browser. I have also deleted and reinstalled this plugin. Still, the user selected image option is not working. I even switched between both options in the pin it button settings, that didn’t work either. I searched other posts on this topic and none of them have helped so far. Please let me know how I can fix this. Thanks.

Ashley @ wwww.joyfulthriftyhome.com

http://wordpress.org/plugins/pinterest-pin-it-button/