i had the same issue and I contacted my host about that after 3 days, I have figured out the problem.. it’s really an issue with yahoo.. so shadow_mal is right, you just need to change the [your-mail] to something.. and make sure to include email address field so you will be able to catch the email address of the sender.. and in gmail, you will have no problem with the reply cuz you just need to click the email address of the sender and you will be able to reply and set his email address as the reply to.. 😉 cuz that is linked to mail:hisemailaddress@yahoo.com
Thank you and God speed!
