Issue solved: Ended up being my Xfinity Router and the “Advanced Security” setting. Turned off Advanced Security and everything started working again.
It’s just 1 site, I have it hosted on a raspberry pi. Some suggested that it’s a firewall issue, I haven’t had the chance yet to test that theory but I will tonight. The raspberry pi is in my house, on my local network. wagswithmags is a domain name we purchased and we used google domains to point to my ip address provided by comcast. And then I set up a port forward for 80 and 443 to point to 10.0.0.11.