jidm,
Brilliant. In query.php, I deleted the “any” and it resolved my issue. Not only were the pages showing up in results but the display was broken. All seems well now, although the site is brand new with little content yet, so I will hold my breath a while. Meanwhile, it looks good. Using WP 2.8.4 and Arras Theme 1.3.5. Just found this too – might be worth a look: http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/search/
Thanks!