pdavisnwa
Forum Replies Created
-
Forum: Requests and Feedback
In reply to: Auto Updates?@samuel Wood (Otto)
Thanks for the answers.
Oddly enough, that’s exactly the sort of reasoning people use to have automatic updates in the first place.
That is people, and from one person to the next, there exists great variance in the priorities they place on this or that thing.
– The API now uses SSL-only, and the relevant root certificates are included in WordPress. Spoofing that would be most difficult because it’s not relying on the network to validate the SSL certificates.
Yes, it used not to, which is why I chose to do SFTP and HTTPS to maintain my sites. Nonetheless, however difficult the protocols chosen by WordPress may be to spoof, it is not impossible. I just prefer to be in control of that risk myself. If it blows up, then I am right there to see it. If it gets hacked because I am compromised, then I know where it came from.
Again, I appreciate your response and your time.
Thank you.
Forum: Requests and Feedback
In reply to: Auto Updates?@chip Bennett
Automatic core updates for minor versions are very, very safe, and have very, very low risk.
While that may be true, it is not “no risk.” The better question is:
“Who is responsible for taking that risk?”
Is it the site owner and maintainer, or WordPress?
I will submit to you and all other, that whoever is taking the risk and paying the bills is the one that gets to decide when updates are done.
Forum: Requests and Feedback
In reply to: Auto Updates?@marj Wyatt
I think the heart of the issue here is that some in both of the developers and in the community have forgotten certain core principles that originally drove WordPress to be open source and GPL in the first place.
I place a certain trust in the open source community that I do not place in the commercial side of the business. Generally, that trust has not been misplaced. However, in a zeal for security, the developers and their defenders have spent currency they did not have. They have forgotten that developers SERVE the community, and not the other way around.
WordPress is a good product. I like it and have recommended it to others. However, I see an attitude rising here among the developers and their defenders that is not good. They need to honestly evaluate why they are doing what they are doing. If the answer is not satisfactory, then the best thing to do is move on.
I was particularly disturbed by Andrew Nevin’s “go find another CMS” reply to me. That is an invitation for people to leave WordPress and reduce it’s user base. It is a counter-productive answer.
I would dearly love to see the chips fall the right way in this matter. I will be disappointed if they do not.
Forum: Requests and Feedback
In reply to: Auto Updates?@samuel Wood (Otto)
You updated to WordPress 3.7. Indeed, that was the main feature of WordPress 3.7. It was front-and-center. Top of the list. Immediately after upgrading, that was the big name feature presented right at the top of the about screen.
I do not know what your life is like, but mine is extremely busy (like a lot of other folks). I do not have time to read fully about every update. If it doesn’t readily appear (and it didn’t) then I miss it (like a lot of other folks, obviously). I barely remember October.
That said, auto-updating carries security risks in an of itself. If WordPress creates a backdoor to update my site, then who else can exploit that backdoor? I have enough security issues to deal with, without another access into my server space.
Simply changing the wp-config file does not shut that backdoor. Apparently I am going to have to plug that hole in other ways as hackers are certain to exploit it in the future. Even if the data sent is in a secure tunnel, or encrypted, IPs and hostnames can be spoofed.
And while you’re perfectly free to criticize the decision, on these forums, you will please keep it civil. There is no cause for using the terms “unscruplous and arrogant” or telling people to “get real”. If you want to criticize, use your words, not your emotions.
Kindly tell me what is uncivil about calling a spade, a spade? I have, over the years, worked with programmers that had the exact attitude displayed by both the WordPress core dev. team and Andrew Nevin. It was an ugly attitude to behold then, and it certainly is not any more attractive now.
You know, from time to time, I get emails from Matt Mullenweg and others concerning things they see as important to WordPress users. Why could not I have gotten an email about this? It is a big deal, and not just to me.
I handle my own updates through SFTP and access the backoffice through HTTPS. I am quite capable of handling my own affairs. However, I apparently placed unreasonable trust in WordPress to respect me as a site owner and user of their software.
That will not happen again.
Forum: Requests and Feedback
In reply to: Auto Updates?@andrew Nevins
So, who deleted part of the conversation where you told me I needed to go to another CMS?
If you didn’t like my reply, you should not have been dismissive toward me.
Kindly put my posts back up, as I was contributing to the topic until you, Andrew, decided to treat me like a child.
WordPress violated basic rules of computing and software. All I did was point that out, and say that it was inexcusable. You then decided to dismiss me as if my concerns were groundless.
Forum: Requests and Feedback
In reply to: Auto Updates?@andrew Nevins
Drink the Kool-aid, bud.
I may leave WordPress, and never recommend them again. However, it would be a more desirable outcome for them to respect their users, don’t you think?
Or is it that you are fully invested in the People’s Temple?
Forum: Requests and Feedback
In reply to: Auto Updates?@andrew Nevins
Who do you think I am?
It really is irrelevant who you are. At this point you are an apologist for the inexcusable conduct of the WordPress team.
That makes you every bit as bad as they are with regard to this matter.
You may be a fine individual in every other respect, but don’t apologize or rationalize the inexcusable breach of the most basic rules of computer usage:
1. Never take control from the user.
2. Never do anything to a user without their permission.These two unwritten codes of conduct have been around since the earliest days of computing. Only the unscruplous and arrogant violate these rules.
Man, I work as a Network Tech in a company with over 400 users. I never touch a users profile without their permisson, unless they have first violated company policy and are under investigation.
Moreover, we tell them upfront in the Computer User Policy that the PC and network they use are subject to change, and updates will be done from time to time without warning.
Now, compare that relationship to the relationship WordPress users have with WordPress. Just where does WordPress get off determining that MY SITE needs to be updated without MY EXPRESS PERMISSION?
In your vernacular: Dude, get real.
Forum: Requests and Feedback
In reply to: Auto Updates?@andrew Nevins
Before 3.7 by default people did have the choice to update minor (and major) releases in WordPress, giving them an informative message to update. I don’t think that worked, as there were too many WordPress websites without fundamental security fixes.
*emphasis mine
Since when did it become WordPress’ or your responsibility to insure that everyone’s site was “up to date?” Last time I checked, I paid for my server space and created my content. WordPress just provides an option for presenting it to the world.
Neither WordPress nor you are responsible for my site’s security: I AM. Why is that so difficult for you to figure out?
This change was done without proper notification or permission from site owners and maintainers.
Forum: Requests and Feedback
In reply to: Auto Updates?You all have violated one of the first rules of computer usage:
Never take control away from the user.
You did, and I am quite upset.
I do not care how “safe” the updates supposedly are. You have NOT tested every possible configuration of WordPress there can be. You will break someone’s site, albeit unintentionally, but broken nonetheless. I wonder, will you contribute your personal time to fixing what you then broke? Will you fix their damaged reputation?
I wonder, do you all think you can undo damage once it has been done? Can you all now magically go back in time and fix a problem you precipitated by your “helpful” feature so there is NO IMPACT?
I seriously doubt it.
The automatic update feature was implemented WITHOUT user permission, and without proper notification – which is an absolute No-No. (I’m sorry, but “read the release notes” is NOT proper notification to the user for such a significant change to the features of the software.)
This implementation, and the replies I read from the WordPress team, smack of arrogance, and a “know-it-all” attitude.
By the way, since when did the WordPress team decide they were God?
The more I think about this, the more upset I get at the utter presumption of such action.
drmikegreen,
Thank you!!! The loop issue has dogged me for over a year. Thank you for your resolution of this very aggravating problem.
Forum: Plugins
In reply to: [WP Super Edit] [Plugin: WP Super Edit] After 3.1 upgrade, plugin broken.Same problem as described above. I did what you said to do ev3rywh3re. However, when I turned every option back on, it still gave me a blank editor area and no buttons.
I did it twice, exactly as you stated. Fail both times. But, the second time I started turning off options on the Configure Editor page. I found that the Font Tools option caused everything to blank out.
Hope this helps.
Could it be your PHP version? I received the following error when trying to activate Mystat.
Plugin could not be activated because it triggered a fatal error.
Parse error: syntax error, unexpected T_STRING, expecting T_OLD_FUNCTION or T_FUNCTION or T_VAR or ‘}’ in /*****/****/****/*****/public_html/blog/wp-content/plugins/mystat/modules/common.class.php on line 4
I did some checking and determined that it was most likely the PHP version that was the cause of the error. I upgraded from PHP 4 to PHP 5 and Mystat activated just fine.
Forum: Fixing WordPress
In reply to: Upgrading to 2.5.1 messed the character encodingIn your wp-config file you will find the following line:
define(’DB_CHARSET’, ‘utf8′);
Comment it out or remove it. This caused me considerable grief when I upgraded a couple of weeks ago. There is a conflict between the way your MySQL database is setup and the above line in the config file.
What I went through figuring it out is detailed here:
http://reproachofmen.org/blog/?p=102
I pray this helps.