Hi Kel,
I had this same issue until I went to check my tags. Go to Posts and then to the Tags submenu. You will then see a listing of your tags and the number of posts that are attached to them. On mine, I see the number “1” listed for each post. So when I run show the Tag Cloud, all of the Tags will be one size, since none of them are greater than 1.
Test it for yourself like I did. Try adding one of your tags to a different post and let me know if the Tag Cloud changes. I think for full effectiveness, we need to go through our posts and add as many tags as possible, so long as they have relevance within the post.
Hope this helps.
Michelle Marie Perron
Perron Insurance Services
http://www.perronservices.com