The theory is correct. Calculations appear normal on new posts. Is there a way to apply these retroactively?
It is quite possible the rating occurred before the 1-9 settings were in place. How best to test that theory w/o interfering with the site. Fake post?
http://sites.davidson.edu/rel176/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Screen-Shot-2014-09-12-at-10.30.47-AM.png
Thanks for responding. I am not using a caching plugin. Any settings that might affect this? Something I’ve overlooked?