Juicermaniac

Ok, so the feed only worked on a different theme, such as the WordPress default Twentyfourteen theme, it did not work with my theme before now.

The problem was that themes from MyThemeShop have a special menu option that says: “Enter your FeedBurner’s URL here, ex: http://feeds.feedburner.com/mythemeshop and your main feed (http://example.com/feed) will get redirected to the FeedBurner ID entered here.)”

On Feedburner they took my URL with “/feed/” and made the feed perfectly (even it if wasn’t showing up for me, they somehow figured it out) then when I put the URL Feedburner gave me into the MyThemeShop option and it worked perfectly!

The main lesson I learned about debugging this is: Use the Twenty Fourteen theme and check your website feed page, if it works then the problem is somewhere in your theme. If your theme is the problem, then look into the theme options and see if you find something that makes a custom RSS feed for that theme! Crazy how there as an option to make the feed there all along, nothing more complex than that.

I just want to say that I resolved my problem!
Here is what I did in case it will help you: (The answer came from kmessinger from http://wordpress.org/support/topic/how-to-fix-the-rss-feed-on-my-site)

He suggested that I activate the Twenty-Thirteen theme and check the feed page to see if it was a theme related problem, well I changed the theme and it was working! So I thought, aha! it’s a theme problem. I re-activated my theme (Splash Theme) and viola the feed was working! So just activating twenty-thirteen (or twenty-twelve, etc.) and re-activating my own theme worked: http://www.juiceitupp.com/feed/

Thanks a lot to the massive community here at wordpress. I almost was in tears after trying to figure this out for hours, but I finally resolved it after reading so many posts.