I forgot to mention that the phantom items are titled “Worship FAQs” and “Easter”. When you click on them, you can see that the pages were removed.
Oh man, I’m sorry–I’m not sure what it was now. But you should be able to find it if you go to that webpage that’s giving you trouble, then press F12 on your keyboard. Click on Script, and you should see error messages coming up, and it will highlight the line of bad code. Good luck!
Nevermind! Under Developer Tools on the IE8 web browser, it indicated that there was one line of code giving an invalid property value error. I found that line of code in the slideshow gallery pro plugin and just deleted it (risky move, I know!) and it worked!