Well… No thanks for the overwhelming response you guys.
I didn’t end up messing with any of the files. I just deactivated all my plugins, checked my page and the sidebar placement was where it was a week ago- the right place.
Kept these plugins (if it helps anyone else in narrowing it down).
wordpress SEO, wordpress popular posts, wordpress font unploader free, tabber tabs widget, social media widget, simply instagram, shareaholic, send email only on reply to my comment, pinterest pin it button, newsletter, lijit search, jetpack by wordpress.com, infolinks official plugin, hello dolly, Growmap Anti Spambot Plugin, Google XML Sitemaps, Google Analytics for WordPress, Content.Ad, CommentLuv, Broken Link Checker, Bottom of every post, Blogger Importer, Akismet
