I liked it. I like being able to highlight a photo in the upper right corner. I liked the three column layout at the bottom.
The whole thing looks very similar to a theme from theundersigned.net that I just tried out, though. I wound up using his StripedPlus.
I have just upgraded from 1.5.3 to 2.0.2. Everything else works except the comments. All my old comments remain, but no one can post new comments. When I click on the comment button, it just opens the same site page again.
I just had the same problem in Firefox. Thankfully, the advice above about removing the wordpress cookies worked. I have just logged back in.
This problem definitely needs to be fixed. It is now August and I see that WordPress has known about this problem since posting began about it months ago!!!!!