After getting no response from the dev I finally gave up and replaced it with “Simple Facebook Comments for WordPress” from David Nelson’s website. That plugin works much easier and required almost zero configuration. Works flawlessly. Check it out if you’re still having problems.
http://www.davidswordpressplugins.com/simple-facebook-comments-for-wordpress/
Tried to delete this post, but can’t seem to find a way to do so. I reposted it with a title like the others. Moderator, please delete this copy.