aneteckers

Mike Dell you are an absolute LEGEND!!!! It worked.
Forever grateful.
For anyone else who has this problem, here is an article I found with instructions on how to change the settings:
https://create.blubrry.com/resources/powerpress/advanced-tools-and-options/premium-podcasting-content/wishlist-member/

Specifically this part:
Modification to allow WishList Member to work with PowerPress

Older versions of WishList Member plugin require a modification to your wp-config.php for PowerPress to override the protected feed behavior built into the membership plugin.

define(‘POWERPRESS_ENCLOSURE_FIX’, true);

Newer versions of WishList Member plugin require a change to your settings to enable podcasting. Go to WishList Member menu and select “Settings”. Under Settings select the “Miscellaneous” tab. Find the setting labeled “Disable RSS Enclosures for non-authenticated feeds” and select “no” then save your changes.

Wishlist Member option to disable enclosures in RSS feeds – Select “no” for podcasting.
Wishlist Member option to disable enclosures in RSS feeds – Select “no” for podcasting.