Moderator
Jan Dembowski
(@jdembowski)
Forum Moderator and Brute Squad
Side note: @hosseinrafiei I’ve moved this topic to Everything else WordPress as this is not a developing topic.
Hi,
Thanks for your feedback @macmanx
I think you should rethink about the algorithm. It’s not accurate. You said that it’s counting the update requests that are received to WordPress server within last 12 hours.
This is not good. My plugin is installed on thousand of websites that may don’t have any visitor in last 12 hours. I suggest you to consider a longer time period. For example 3 months. As I said based on my own stats my plugin’s active installs should be more than 7K but in the WordPress, users are seeing 3000+!
Also what about those plugins that don’t use WordPress Repositories for the update and use their own servers for providing update packages?
Additionally, I want to ask you to don’t round the number on thousands. It will be very better if you round it based on hundreds. For example showing 3100+ or 3900+ will be very better.
Thanks for your consideration.
Regards,
Hossein Rafiei
I’ll leave the rest to @otto42 if he wishes to share some thoughts on that, but I can definitely answer this one:
Also what about those plugins that don’t use WordPress Repositories for the update and use their own servers for providing update packages?
Being in the repository is a requirement of being in the directory at https://wordpress.org/plugins/
So, with regards to how active installs are counted in the directory, plugins hosted elsewhere are irrelevant.
You said that it’s counting the update requests that are received to WordPress server within last 12 hours.
You misunderstand. WordPress has a schedule to perform update checks every 12 hours, but as you know, some sites may not receive hits in that time.
We’re not looking only at “the last 12 hours”, because as you point out, that’s silly. We remember what sites contacted us and when and we expire “old sites” in a much more reasonable timeframe.
But no, I’m not going to tell you what that timeframe is. People do attempt to “game” our systems, and that information is simply a bit too much secret sauce to give out. Nevertheless, we do retain information for a time and we’re not being silly about the number there. We believe it to be accurate, or at least, consistent across the directory.
