Trying to print only a certain section

I help manage farmhousesoul.com and we are trying to set up the print button to only print out a certain part of a post such as a recipe and only it’s ingredients. We don’t want the picture that’s part of the post or any other information, just the list of ingredients. I have been spending countless hours trying to resolve this issue, but no luck. What am I doing wrong? I even attempted to use the CSS tag, “print-only” but that hasn’t gotten me anywhere either.

What to do now?

-Thanks
Jordan

https://wordpress.org/plugins/printfriendly/