Site not shown

I authenticated and reauthenticated the plugin to my Google Analytics account. In the Google Analytics Console I can see information about the site. However, the drop down for the profile does not show the site. It shows two sites that I control / am webmaster for. One is also part of the Google Analytics property selection, but the other is not.

I’d appreciate any help getting this to work, as I have heard good things about your plugin.
(I originally loaded it while you were running your AppSumo special, but had the same problem, so deactivated it and lost out on the special.)

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]