Redirection using URL and login status

Hi! Probably a newbie question you might have answered a thousand times, but I couldn’t find the right answer and I’m feeling frustrated about it.

I set a redirection rule using URL and login status: logged-out users are set to be redirected to page A, and logged-in users to page B. On the frontend, logged-out users are redirected to the right page (page A), but logged-in users are redirected to page A also, instead of being redirected to page B.

I’m getting crazy about this, and I know it’s supposed to work simply as it should be, but somehow I can’t make it work. I’ve tried all different combinations of options for that rule and yet nothing. My webhost is SiteGround, which has its own built-in cacher plugin. Maybe that’s the reason… Dunno. Thank you in advance for your help and congratulations for this referential plugin!