Hi there,
This is strange. The template file is rating-form.php and it seems to be missing the rating items… So you have rating items added to the rating form? What type of rating items are they? Can you try a select, star or radio and see what happens? Are you using custom images?
Can you also try re-saving your styles settings. In particular the icon font library settings for Font Awesome.
Daniel
Think i figured out a solution – i simply deactivated the plugin and reactivated it and now the stars reappeared. Probably should have tried that earlier. Thanks!