Hello Gerobe, TxAggie08 and Qurl.
I am asking something rather unorthodox and that is if you guys might be so willing/open/awesome to take a look at my post regarding a rather similar issue with wordpress 3.5. Different plugin, similar problem. I tired messing around with it but had no luck.
Yes, I know this is a different plugin and this forum is for this plugin.
However, You guys seem awesome, look like you know your way(s) around plugins and figured I would give this a shot.
Plugin in question: WordPress Popup
Thanks in advance!