Font Style Issues

How did you change the font? You could use this custom CSS to change the font of the bulleted lists:

.post-content ul, ol {
	font-family: "Georgia";
}

Alternatively, you could use this custom CSS to change the font of the entire post, but doing it this way would also change the font of your headers “Ingredients” and “Instructions”:

.post-content {
	font-family: "Georgia";
}

It’s possible that your theme’s built-in customization options don’t cover the lists, and as you are using a commercial theme, I can’t download the theme and check for myself. Your best bet would be to contact the theme’s vendors for help. After all, that’s part of what you paid for.

Did you try the custom CSS I recommended? You can either use your theme’s built-in custom CSS option, if one exists, or a custom CSS plugin.