I am having the same issue.
@kelseadaniels – Are you using the “On Entire Site” targeting option?
@peregrine12 – You have a JS error on your home page only. It appears that only your home page is loading multiple (3+) copies of jQuery including one from google apis. That is the cause of it not working on that page. Likely your template for the home page is adding in extra <script src="" which should be avoided for WP generally speaking.
Hope that helps.
Thank you for looking into that and discovering the conflicting scripts. That is probably the problem, however my client has requested that I not use a pop up for this application. I do appreciate your responsiveness and will remember this plugin for future needs.
Yes, I am using the “on entire site” option. I just want the pop up to be on the homepage. https://www.sassyyou.com
@kelseadaniels – Do you still have popup maker active, I see you have a popup there already created using another method.