• Dear Smart COD Support Team,

    I am using Smart COD for WooCommerce (Free Version 1.9.9) on my online store, https://buvart.eu, based in Slovenia.

    I am interested in enabling COD Protection, with the Minimum Successful COD Rate set to 100%.

    My goal is to prevent customers who have previously failed to collect a shipped Cash on Delivery (COD) parcel from using COD again, while still allowing them to pay using other available payment methods.

    Before enabling this feature, I would like to clarify how your plugin handles the following situations:

    1. Uncollected COD parcel

    The order is shipped, but the customer does not collect the parcel. It is returned to us, and we change the WooCommerce order status to “Cancelled”.

    In this situation, we would like COD to be unavailable for the customer’s future orders.

    2. Cancellation before shipment

    A customer cancels an order before it has been shipped. We also change the status to “Cancelled”.

    In this case, we do not want to restrict the customer’s future COD payments.

    3. Return after successful delivery

    The customer receives and pays for the parcel, but later exercises their right to return the goods within the return period. The payment is refunded.

    We believe such orders should be marked as “Refunded”, not “Cancelled”. Please confirm whether this is correct for your COD Protection system.

    Our order status workflow:

    • Processing: Order received and remains in this status while the parcel is in transit.
    • Completed: Changed only after the postal service confirms successful delivery and payment.
    • Cancelled: Used for uncollected parcels and cancellations before shipment.
    • Refunded: Intended for returns after successful delivery and reimbursement.

    My questions:

    1. Does COD Protection distinguish between an uncollected parcel and an order cancelled before shipment?
    2. How does the plugin determine whether a parcel was actually shipped?
    3. Does a refunded order negatively affect a customer’s COD success rate?
    4. Is a 100% minimum successful COD rate suitable for blocking COD after one confirmed uncollected parcel?
    5. Does the Free version support this functionality, or is Smart COD PRO required?
    6. What customer information is transmitted to your external COD Protection service, and how is it handled under GDPR?

    Thank you very much for your assistance.

    Kind regards,

    Buvart Fashion
    https://buvart.eu
    Slovenia

Viewing 1 replies (of 1 total)
  • Plugin Author FullStack-ing

    (@fullstackhouse)

    Hi Robert,

    Thanks for explaining how Buvart Fashion handles COD orders. The Free version can hide Cash on Delivery after one qualifying failure at your store, while keeping your other enabled payment methods available. With Minimum Successful COD Rate set to 100%, previous successful deliveries cannot override a qualifying failure matched to the shopper’s email or phone number.

    1. Shipped but uncollected. When the parcel comes back and you mark the order as Cancelled, it can count as a failure if there’s evidence of dispatch. Free looks for tracking saved on the WooCommerce order, a prior Completed status on a physical order, or a transition from a recognized Shipped or Fulfilled status. It reads those signals from WooCommerce without querying the courier.
    2. Cancelled before shipping. Because you use Processing both before dispatch and in transit, that status alone cannot distinguish the two cases. For stores without a recognized tracking integration, we use a lower-confidence fallback. A cancellation from Processing can qualify once at least 24 hours have passed since the order was placed. We chose that minimum to filter out quick cancellations while still giving stores without tracking a way to use their order history. The time elapsed gives us no confirmation that the parcel shipped, so a pre-dispatch cancellation after 24 hours can still qualify. For your workflow, I’d keep Completed for confirmed delivery and use a supported integration to record tracking on the order when the parcel actually ships.
    3. Delivered, paid, then returned. Yes, record a full refund through WooCommerce so the order becomes Refunded. COD Protection excludes it from both the current successful-delivery count and the failed-delivery count. WooCommerce refund guide

    Tracking integrations recognized by Free 1.9.10

    • WooCommerce Shipment Tracking
    • Advanced Shipment Tracking (AST and AST Pro), plus TrackShip when tracking is saved in the shared WooCommerce shipment tracking format
    • WooCommerce Order Tracking by WebExpert / Opportus
    • YITH WooCommerce Order Tracking, using the Free version’s tracking format
    • AfterShip for WooCommerce
    • PluginHive WooCommerce Shipment Tracking Pro, with its WooCommerce Shipment Tracking compatibility option enabled

    Which postal service and WooCommerce tracking plugin do you use? That will help us confirm whether the tracking is saved where Smart COD can read it and whether PRO can verify outcomes with your courier.

    What data is shared? When COD Protection is enabled, checkout sends hashed email or phone identifiers for matching, along with the installation ID and country. Signed updates can include new physical COD orders and their later outcomes, as well as eligible past cancellations. The data can include pseudonymized order and postcode identifiers, statuses, timestamps, amounts, shipping methods and tracking details where available. Raw customer names, email addresses, phone numbers and street addresses are excluded. Pseudonymized data can still be personal data under GDPR. Turning the feature off stops future collection, sharing and checkout checks. COD Protection data-use details

    Where PRO differs. Free covers the same-store rule you described. Smart COD PRO can also use eligible delivery history from other participating stores in Slovenia, when available, even on a shopper’s first order with you. When a tracking number is available from a supported courier, PRO checks the courier’s API for the actual shipment outcome, including delivery, return, or an explicit refusal. These courier-reported outcomes are recorded separately from WooCommerce cancellations. Slovenia’s courier integrations are already in progress and to be delivered soon. Courier integrations and coverage

    In PRO, shoppers who select Cash on Delivery also see data-use information within the payment method, with a link to more details. This helps inform shoppers when your store relies on legitimate interest as its legal basis for COD Protection.

    Best,
    Smart COD Support

Viewing 1 replies (of 1 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.