Can’t update default settings on tabs

Hi, I am using this plugin on my site, and in general its great. I got it to look exactly how i want it here: http://77.104.154.77/~flashli8/sgdevsite/being-frank/

But when I try to save as default settings, it doesnt work, and the other tabs on other pages dont change. (See: http://77.104.154.77/~flashli8/sgdevsite/maddis-fridge/ and http://77.104.154.77/~flashli8/sgdevsite/too-much-glue/ as examples).

How can I globally change the settings to match the first page?