Multiple Instances on same page

I am using this short code to get a list of custom content here is an example:

<ul>
    [loop type="th_sermons" th_sermons_speaker="speaker1" count="10"]
        <li>[field title]</li>
    [/loop]
</ul>

<ul>
    [loop type="th_sermons" th_sermons_speaker="speaker2" count="10"]
        <li>[field title]</li>
    [/loop]
</ul>

It loops twice, but only returns the content of the first loop. What am I doing wrong? You can see it here: http://rlcfchurch.org/sermons/

https://wordpress.org/plugins/custom-content-shortcode/