Thanks for the link TJ Post, now Its working on my site again.
Also would like to add that My problem was also solved after de-activating the plugin. I can’t even re-activate now though for some reason. Not that I would want to till a fix gets found.
I really hope this gets fixed/updated so I can continue using it. Every other counter I tried only lets me use their default designs. But I have my own counter image designs I want to use.