roeshead

Well, the maker of the theme was much more responsive than I thought he would be (I know the people here are always responsive so thank you for that). Turns out that the theme was using a custom password form. Once I removed the code to use that, it worked just fine.

If you don’t know if your theme uses a custom password form (like I didn’t realize mine did), looking in the theme’s functions.php file for something like:

add_filter(‘the_password_form’, ‘custom_password_form’);

Thanks esmi for your help.

I switched to Twenty Eleven theme and it worked then I switched back to Supermassive theme by ThemeForest and it works within that browser that I tested Twenty Eleven on but not my other browsers or machines.

This suggests to me that there’s something in the Supermassive theme that is blocking the cookie being created. How is that handled differently now in WordPress 3.4 than WordPress 3.3.2 (where Supermassive worked just fine)? How can I even troubleshoot this?

This is a live site so I don’t have time to wait for Themeforest to “look into it”. I’ll need to solve this issue on my own quickly.

Thanks for any insight.

That plugin is awesome. Thanks tremedously.