Looks like the problem is a redirection issue. After disabling all my plugins the lack of redirection was fixed. I then re-enabled my plugins.
I haven’t yet re-enabled All-in-one WP Security. If I have any issues when I re-enable it, I’ll post again.
Thanks for the speedy response. You have to be right that there’s a redirection problem. Hostgator disabled all my plugins and the problem fixed itself. Then I re-enabled the plugins and all is good.