I was having the same problem. Jetpack was just updated to 5.2.1. Everything works fine now. Thanks for logging the bug!
Hi Tracey,
I changed the reply-to address to an admin email address on our domain. However, you do have to be careful when replying to someone’s query. You need to manually input their email address in the “to” field, otherwise you send your reply right back to yourself.
Best wishes,
Frances
Unfortunately, no go. I ended up switching to Contact Form 7, which allowed me to edit the “Reply-to” field.
Thanks! I’m traveling, will try it as soon as possible.