If anybody else needs help with this, go here – http://wordpress.org/support/topic/216981
All I ended up doing was copying and pasted the entire main index template into a page template, and then removing the stuff I didn’t want.
I looked a bit, and it seems like there’s only one instance. I don’t know anything about php yet, so I don’t know what to do about it really. I think it’s treating pages as articles, basically.
Thank you. I will try to remember to post again after seeing if it works or not.