Importing with incorrect time

I’m having a weird issue with imported events coming in with the wrong time. (Well, sort of. This is a really really strange issue!) Here is what is happening:

1. My WordPress setting are all correct to my time zone.

2. The events I am importing are local to my time zone.

3. When I import an event, if I go to view the event, it shows the times as four hours too early.

4. When I go into the editor to correct the times, they show up as the correct time in the editor already, NOT what it is showing on the published page.

Here is an example. I imported this event:

https://www.facebook.com/events/674018956114186/

The event starts at 9:30 AM. But when I import and then view the page, it says 5:30 AM:

http://manisteelove.com/event/communication-workshop/?instance_id=1118

Then when I go to edit the event, the start time in the editor already says 9:30 AM.

The only solution I have found is to import events, then open each one in the editor and hit save to make it show the correct time. My eventual plan is to upgrade so that I can fully automate this task, but I worry that without physically going in to edit the times after import, my calendar will be loaded with incorrect info.

Please help!