After posting last night I did some troubleshooting and ..
Ahhhh! I've been working on this all night. help, anyone!
On all my pages reguardless of ID, I get this for the link to add comment
http://waprogressives.org/wordpress/?page_id=10You must be o post a comment
I tried changing the permalinks and changed the comments.php with the default theme code still no luck. Reloaded the theme, still not working. This is the second theme I've used with this problem. It displays normal after you login, but if I logout and go back,still the error.
Any help would be a blessing. Thanks