2 Home Pages

Not 100% sure however, i vaguely remember my wife having this problem with her site at one point in time.
I think i solved it by looking at menu items and pages. (both of these are able produce menu items…hence two pages with same name).

You may need to choose one or the other (pages or menus) if you want to keep it simple…otherwise it gets very complicated trying to remember whats going on!

I have wordpress set up so that menu items are automatically created when i create a new page. Works for me!