Redirection by User Level Issue (Specifically Administrators)

Hi, I really like the plugin, but have noticed an issue. I have the redirection setting set to redirect subscribers to a specific page (a members home page). However administrators are now also being redirected to this page, then when they click the dashboard link from the top of the page (WP Toolbar) it logs them out. Another note is that all but one user has this behavior, the user that was used in first creating the site (also an admin) works fine, once you login it sends you to the dashboard (like it should). Any suggestions are greatly appreciated.

Thank you in advance!!!

http://wordpress.org/plugins/theme-my-login/