Unverified Can STILL read Private Posts

I unchecked read private posts for the unverified role, but when I test it out with an unverified acccount – I can still see the private posts.

Here is the site, if that helps:
http://thepalomainstitute.com/students

FYI, when looking at the page above a random person should see nothing in the student area, an unverified role ALSO sees nothing, But a subscriber would see a test post there. (The problem is I believe that unverified roles can see the test post.)

How can I fix this?

http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/user-role-editor/