Search not including titles

The search function on my site is only working for the body content of posts, not for post titles, e.g. if you searched for “Phantom” it would find anything with “Phantom” in the body content, but not if the title of the post was “Phantom of the Opera”. We’re a reviews website so it’s very important people can search for specific reviews!

It wouldn’t work on the standard search so I installed the Relevanssi and it won’t work for that either.

Any suggestions?

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]