Total Counts wrong after site migration

Were there any changes in the urls of webpages in this transition? If you are not sure, let us know the staging and production urls of any of your webpages.

As the urls of the staging and production websites are different and shares are tracked on url basis, it’s highly likely that shares will be different for both the websites.
P.S.: Our plugin doesn’t show “Total Counts” at “Edit page” section.

The option in the screenshot is not total share count. It’s the initial shares you want to show for Facebook share icon. You can try changing the saved shares “88” to some other value and check the shares at the webpage to confirm if the shares are getting multiplied by two.
Shares are saved in the _heateor_ss_shares_meta meta key in the “postmeta”
Other than that, you can try checking the current Facebook shares for any webpage using following official Facebook API. Just replace the “URL” with the actual url for which you want to fetch shares:
https://graph.facebook.com/?id=URL
For example, to see the Facebook shares for homepage of your website, visit https://graph.facebook.com/?id=http://superbooksingapore.com/