As someone else here stated: great idea, poor execution.
I was looking for a plugin that would consolidate comments like this and I thought that I'd found a solution. When I installed and activated this plugin, it caused ALL links on each post page to stop working. Mouse over them and nothing. I then posted in the author's forum here, but no response.
It's a shame that this plugin is being ignored and is no longer functional.
Excellent comment system
Love the functionality of this plugin. Works great.
I love that I can keep my comments as well as incorporate social media comments.
Just what I was looking for!
If you're able to add twitter too that would be super!
1. I would love it to include a clean-looking spam filter
2. I would like to see all the comments from all sites in one collective tab. It's kind of weird that they're separate.
3. Nested comments would be great!
4. If I could have anything it would be combined with a sign-in with google feature for added spam protection (I tried to do this manually and it was hell.)
5. Thats it. Its beautiful and I love it. Mostly because I think Google is going to rule the world pretty soon and think the websites integrated with Google will be right there with them ruling it. Eventually you guys are going to have to create a way to integrate BuddyPress comments into Google Comments. ;)
Thank you Brandon.
Installed the plugin. Takes ages to load comments, if it does at all. Disappointing. Especially because I really like the idea.
Smart! Would love the show number of comments for each social site!! Keep up the great work dude!
The tabs thing is not an issue, since I can see how it would be pretty difficult to make those interact with each other. For me however, the main problem is the comments not registering as actual comments, and as a result not being counted as comments on wordpress.
It makes the plugin way less versatile with other wordpress plugin-ins such as adding most commented post in a page, and adding recent comments as a widget.
Still good job.
This is indeed an awesome plugin... or at least in theory. As to expect with all plugins, they can break down or be buggy, but the support is slim to none, so don´t expect the author to come to your aid if something goes wrong.
This is a great work. As some have stated before, a consolidated view of the comments all at once would be more beneficial when it comes to a user-friendly experience.
One problem I found from my own experience is that with the HeatMap AdAptive Theme (and I saw other users having this problem with other themes, too) the counting of the comments does not work correctly since it only counts the WordPress comments.
Other than that, this plugin is one of the best ones I have seen. It is well designed, well coded and very clean. Next to this, the little problems and the fact that comments are separated into tabs seem to be "unimportant", so I give this a deserved 4.
Note: I can't understand, though, why people are so negative about the tabs thing since if not for this plugin, most people would be putting only one service on their blogs. It could be better thought to eliminate the tabs (or give the option to, which would be the perfect solution), but come on, this is great work, I hope the author keeps it up to this high level!
You must log in to submit a review. You can also log in or register using the form near the top of this page.