Forgot to mark as resolved 🙂
Figured it out. CF7 uses the wordpress “Comment Blacklist” under Settings>Discussion, and it had a few common words in the list. So any text in any of the fields that contained one of those words caused the email to be blocked.
It does appear its only happening with certain email addresses in the [your-email] fields. Which I’m not sure why CF7 would care what email address is in there. Some addresses are triggering “spam: true”
Another note, Akismet isn’t installed, how are the messages being marked as spam?