Thank you SO MUCH Jayce53! Following that article (http://support.easyrecipeplugin.com/knowledge-base/how-to-make-easyrecipe-display-ziplist-posts/) and having EasyRecipe display my Ziplist recipes totally worked!
After clicking to have EasyRecipe display my Ziplist formatted recipes, all of my recipes now show up under my EasyRecipe design. PHEW! So much easier than manually copy and pasting each recipe over. That would have taken HOURS!
After "deactivating" my Ziplist plugin, my visual editor now works perfectly. But all my recipes are still displaying perfectly. Such a lifesaver! Glad everything is back to normal.
And in my very humble opinion, I have had MUCH better luck ranking higher in Google and having Google display the "recipe image" next to my recipe link when I use EasyRecipe plugin. I think when the image shows up people are much more likely to click to read that recipe. I've done recipes with both plugins, and the EasyRecipe ones always rank higher with image snippets. Just my experience.
Hope this helps!