Wrong reply email

I am setting up MailPoet for the first time. Everything looks good. I set up SendGrid as well and received confirmation that it was good to go. Then I sent myself a test newsletter, and replied to it from my own email account. The reply went to the wrong email. It went to info@avatarlogs.com which is nonexistent, so it bounced. I thought I had filled in a blank to customize reply email. I had filled in fpb.avatar@gmail.com under MailPoet>Settings>Basics>Sender of Notifications. What am I doing wrong? Thank you, Carol Parker http://avatarlogs.com

https://wordpress.org/plugins/wysija-newsletters/