I know this response seems like a blow off of your issue, but it’s real and true. WordPress is a volunteer driven project. Would you like to volunteer to help with this? Even if you don’t, do you know some of those “young” people who like to document things? See https://make.wordpress.org/docs/
Also, each doc page should have a feedback link, so as you find time, please provide constructive feedback.
update: Another thought. Yes, you’ve posted in the forums, but the forums are for tech support and the people who make decisions and do the work are probably not going to see your post. Decisions get made, things get done by the people who “show up”. If you want to make change, “show up”.
It’s not about contributing to the current docs, whole wordpress.org needs to be rebuilt from ground up. If anything will kill wordpress than nostalgic people.
> It’s not about contributing to the current docs
Yes. It is.
In fact everything in a FOSS ecosystem is exclusively about contributing.
I encourage you take your skills and provide insight if nothing else. If you provide your comments in the right space, then things can be actionable.
Take your pick as to where you think you can make a differnece:
needs to be rebuilt from ground up
The system exists in very well defined sections, and they are always getting iterated on, but wiping the slate clean and starting over is always a bad idea.
The truth is that everybody thinks they would do everything different, when they are a young programmer. And then they actually try to do it, and end up having to solve the same problems as the previous version did, because when they wiped that slate clean, they lost all the accumulated knowledge and fixes for problems that were built into it.
It’s never a good idea to start over fresh. It’s a better idea to build on top of what came before, replace what needs replacing, and fix what needs fixing. What you’re discussing is basically redoing a theme. That’s it. Not starting over. Just making a visual change in how you access and display the data. Doesn’t change all the stuff that underlies it.
Also, React isn’t made from magic beans. It has issues too.
@otto42 This is what I meant with nostalgic feelings will let this project fall behind sooner or later.
Forum Moderator and Brute Squad
*Reads. Drink coffee nostalgically.*
Here’s the problem: except for stating “Young! New! Cool!” you have not identified a problem that needs fixing. You have identified an issue (known one too) about the development documentation. You can contribute there if you like.
You are going to have to do better to explain yourself if you want your idea to even be considered. Nothing you posted explains that and I have no idea what “nostalgia feelings” have to do with a site that works.
Does it work perfectly? No, of course not. But React.js is in no means a magic panacea and any site that has been around and working will have problems from way back.
Doing it all over from scratch doesn’t change that or fix those problems.
Here’s my take @jeremiva is complaining without offering actual constructive solutions. That’s clear.
Is the existing system perfect? Of course not. Heck even paid solutions aren’t perfect and wordpress and its associated sites/knowledge bases etc are all done by volunteers giving up their own time.
It doesn’t appear to have held wordpress back much as far as the general use is concerned, so those valuable free developer efforts are best focused elsewhere.
We have saying here in Australia “put up or shut up”. Which is a succinct way of saying – if you aren’t paying, and aren’t willing to become part of the solution by volunteering, then you have no right to complain.
We have saying here in Australia “put up or shut up”.
I believe that is “G’day, put up or shut up, mate”, but point taken. 🤪
Nevertheless, his point is that that particular site design seems old. And he’s right, there’s nothing wrong with stating that.
But the site design is fungible. It’s just a theme. Themes are easy to remake. It’s not a case of a complete overhaul. That’s one of the advantages of WordPress, themes can be redone without complete site changes.
Constructive feedback would be to address the theme directly, which is also open source, BTW: https://meta.trac.wordpress.org/browser/sites/trunk/wordpress.org/public_html/wp-content/themes/pub/wporg-developer
If somebody wants to start a project to make a better theme using react or whatever the fad of the day is, then more power to them. That’s the great thing about it, anybody can contribute in the way they know best.