Hey there,
FYI the post visibility settings have nothing do with PMPro. If a post is protected with the “Require Membership” box, you shouldn’t be able to view it without that membership level. If this isn’t happening, you have a conflict somewhere.
> but once someone registers they then also get the separate password required screen, which I do not want.
Sorry, but could you explain what is happening a bit clearer? This is very unusual.
> just want every page on my site beyond the homepage to require registration/logging in, and I can’t figure out how to do this.
In that case, you can hook into template_redirect, check for membership with pmpro_hasMembershipLevel() and redirect away with wp_redirect().
If you need further help, please consider becoming a PMPro member for our member support forums.
Hope that helps!
Thanks,
Jess
Thanks for the response Jess, I appreciate it. I usually always upgrade to the paid versions of plugins for the additional features and support once I know a plugin will work for me, but this is the first time I’ve encountered a plugin that just won’t work on my site. I’ve tried deactivating almost all my other plugins to see if it is interaction, but nothing has fixed it so far. I’m concerned I’ll pay to upgrade and then the plugin still won’t end up being able to work on my site and it will be a waste.
Have you tried switching your theme to a default WordPress theme such as twentyfourteen? If you do and the problem persists, there is a theme conflict somewhere. If you post on the member forums, we can log in to your site and help you find out what’s causing it.