Ok, after spending 3 days looking I finally found a poll plugin that allows multiple questions (Colored Vote Polls http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/colored-vote-polls/) - but I hate the way it looks!
See it here http://trueidiocy.us/ (I think you'll have to vote to see what I'm talking about)
How would I make the results look like the results of a normal poll? Maybe a percentage and partial bar... and how would I tweak this plugin so that I could have different answers for each question?
Evaluate (http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/evaluate/) looked the way I wanted, but couldn't vote on multiple questions with one button...
Or is there a different plugin that would do what I want that I somehow missed in my search?