I didn’t want the page to appear in the navbar, and I’ve done what I’m supposed to to prevent that.
Are you using a custom menu? That should let you control what shows up in the menu.
http://codex.wordpress.org/WordPress_Menu_User_Guide
I was using the menu that was generated by wordpress.
I ended up having to create a brand new menu and using that as my main menu. I then deleted the old page and just recreated it, and in the new menu, deleted that page. That worked. Funky bug, funky workaround.
Closing the thread. Thanks for the help.