Too bad it's not responsive.

It works as advertised, and it would have been perfect if it was 2010. However, nowadays, where almost any decent theme is responsive (free or premium), a plugin like this is obsolete from the get go.

If it gets updated and becomes responsive, this plugin is definitely a 4 or even 5 star plugin in my book. And it does not deserve a 1 or even 2 star rating, since it delivers what it promised, hence my 3 star rating.