This is the custom login plugin you've been looking for.

I spent more than a week trying all the different custom login plugins out there, but none of them did everything I needed. I started looking into teaching myself to build my login page from scratch (not my skill set, nor anything I had time for) when I finally stumbled over this plugin. This. Is. The. One. Loginstyle is everything I needed. So many options. The only way you’ll be able to tweak your login page more is to code it from the ground up. I’m so glad I found it. Thank you, Archtheme. I love this plugin. Great work.