Theme recommendations

HI all 🙂 my website is getting more traffic than normal and I’m trying to kick up my SEO but before I really bump it up, I’m looking to tighten the theme. My plugins are a mess, my CSS is a mess and so I’m feeling like just starting fresh since I’ve been using the same theme and such for 3 years. I’d like to find a good ‘newspaper’ type theme that preferably already has built in Classified and is social media ready (facebook, twitter, etc.) so I was hoping to get some recommendations for the community. Right now, I can’t even get a themed registration page going on my current template no matter what it seems. I’ve tried several plugins and they’re all just making it worse LOL

The website is http://www.ParanormalUtopia.com

I’m also interested in the same theme idea for another domain of mine that I will be using for non profit purposes so i’m hoping to find something comfortable that I can work with for awhile. Thanks in advance! 🙂

[ Please do not bump, that’s not permitted here. ]