Submitted Reviews disappear

I am working on a new site and copying & pasting reviews from the client’s old site. I input the review and click submit. I get an email saying there’s a new review with a link, but when I follow the link, it says no reviews are pending, and they’re not showing up anywhere. I am using Genesis-based Outreach theme (by Studiopress). http://karate.wpengine.com/about-eric-menard/testimonials/

http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/wp-customer-reviews/